August 22, 2011

when you’d use high-speed flash sync / Auto FP

Going to High-Speed Flash sync, ie, over maximum flash sync speed, comes with a penalty. So here’s a solid recipe for when it makes most sense to go to high-speed flash sync / Auto FP.

When you need
either
- shallow depth-of-field, or
- fast shutter speeds,
and
- you have the flash power to spare.

As mentioned in the tutorial on high-speed flash sync (HSS), there is a considerable loss of power in going into high-speed flash sync territory. So you wouldn’t immediately use HSS in very bright light if you are trying to over-power the sun with flash. While the higher shutter speeds brings the ambient exposure down, it brings the effective flash power down faster than it affects the ambient light. So the sweet spot will always be at maximum flash sync speed. Therefore, using HSS shouldn’t just be a default way of working flash.

With this image, the softbox was close enough to Aleona that we were able to get good flash exposure on her, even at a high shutter speed. However, we did remove the one baffle of the softbox.


A fun image taken during an individual workshop today  - our model, Aleona caught-mid-air … with a fast shutter speed and flash, to freeze the movement. Even Jessica, my assistant with the ‘tood, was positively elevated with the experience of photographing Aleona.

camera settings: 1/1000 @ f4 @ 800 ISO
Nikon D3s  (B&H);  Nikon 24-70mm f2.8 AF-S (B&H)

 

summary

Use high-speed flash sync when you need the higher shutter speed OR shallower depth field, AND can afford the subsequent loss in power.

 

equipment used during this part of the photo session

Nikon D3s  (B&H);  Nikon 24-70mm f2.8 AF-S (B&H)
Lastolite EZYBOX Softbox Kit (24×24) (B&H)
Nikon SB-900 (B&H);  Nikon SD-9 battery pack (B&H)
(2x) PocketWizard FlexTT5 transceiver (B&H)
PocketWizard AC3 Zone Controller (B&H)

 

{ 31 comments… read them below or add one }

1 mshafik August 23, 2011 at 2:37 am

Best photo I’ve seen for you Neil, that was a refreshing post. :-)

Reply

2 Allen August 23, 2011 at 3:07 am

Eat your heart out, Isaac Newton!

Reply

3 phil August 23, 2011 at 3:53 am

My favorite outdoor setup these days, Neil. Love the shallow DOF.
Great shots and inspiration as usual :)

Reply

4 -cr August 23, 2011 at 3:54 am

With these fun shots, it’s hard to focus on the text. :-)
The more people there are “levitating” in the shots, the more surreal they look. I love it!

Reply

5 Neil vN August 23, 2011 at 3:56 am

I couldn’t levitate to the extent the two girls did. It has something to do with my power-to-mass ratio.

Also, it’s tough to jump with a Nikon D3 and Nikon 70-200mm f2.8 …. that’s a heavy combo that I had to swing upwards before jumping, just to get some momentum to the camera and lens!

Neil vN

Reply

6 Tid August 23, 2011 at 3:58 am

What was the flash used in the box?

Reply

7 Neil vN August 23, 2011 at 7:10 am

Tid, it was a speedlight. In this case, the Nikon SB-900 (B&H)

Neil vN

Reply

8 Jeff Mason August 23, 2011 at 8:43 am

No one ever seems to mention the use of neutral density filters. It seems to me that this is good way to cut down the ambient light into a range where the flash and camera would not be operating in high speed sync mode. Aside from not having enough hands to juggle a filter along with everything else, am I missing something here?

Reply

9 Neil vN August 23, 2011 at 9:09 am

Jeff, a neutral density filter works wonders when you want that shallow depth-of-field without sacrificing the flash power.

But a ND filter wouldn’t help you in a case like the two photos at the top, where there is action and you want to freeze the movement. Then you need the faster shutter speed.

With the image of Aleona jumping, I was chasing the faster shutter speed, not the shallow DoF.

Neil vN

Reply

10 Mary-Claire August 23, 2011 at 9:19 am

Thanks for making me smile this morning! Especially loved the last shot.

Reply

11 Motti August 23, 2011 at 9:24 am

Hi Neil,

Funny and refreshing!

I was under the impression that high speed sync can only go to 1/400 (in the Nikon anyway). I guess it’s the PW that gives you the higher speed sync? Just out of curiosity, would it fair to say that you are using about ten times more flash power this way?

Cheers,
Motti

Reply

12 Neil vN August 23, 2011 at 9:28 am

Nope … it’s not due to the PocketWizards.

Put a speedlight on your camera, and …

if you have a Canon, hit the lightning symbol on the back of your speedlight, or …

if you have a Nikon, it is most likely custom function E1 to enable Auto FP mode, …

and then crank up the shutter speed. See where you end up.

Neil vN

Reply

13 Brian Carey August 23, 2011 at 9:47 am

Cool, great work!

Reply

14 Stephen August 23, 2011 at 11:10 am

You can depend on Neil and Jessica for some very good outtakes. :-)

The reference shot of Jessica near Aleona really is sobering. You aren’t kidding when you state that HSS cuts the effective flash range by half or more. Jessica is really close to the model: 2-3 feet.

Reply

15 Neil vN August 23, 2011 at 11:13 am

Keep in mind that this was shot at 24mm … so there is some spatial distortion.

For starters, Aleona is a 6’1″ (or 6’2″) Russian goddess / model / dancer. Jessica is … less majestically tall. But in this image, Aleona looks much smaller than Jessica.

So the softbox wasn’t quite as close as 2 ft, but yes, HSS kills substantial amounts of flash power the higher you go up in shutter speed.

Neil vN

Reply

16 Stephen August 23, 2011 at 11:14 am

Neil,
Two more questions:
1) Dynamic AF on the Aleona’s eyes? Even though this is not sports photography, Aleona’s eyes are fairly sharp.

2) Machine gunning the shutter or taking the shot at the height of the jump (anticipation)? I figure machine gunning would be bad since the flash would not have time to recharge.

Reply

17 Neil vN August 23, 2011 at 11:18 am

Pre-focus using Single AF mode. Remember, she is jumping vertically in relation to the camera.

Nope, you can’t machine gun with the softbox, since the flash is firing close to full power.

With the shot of the three of us jumping, Jeff did fire it at 9 frames per second, with the speedlight firing with every shot. But these were just short blips of light.

Neil vN

Reply

18 Belinda McCarthy August 23, 2011 at 1:32 pm

Awesome shot! Nice explanation too, clear and easy to comprehend.

Reply

19 Stephen August 23, 2011 at 2:38 pm

Neil,
Thanks for the reply! I was too busy being entranced by the freeze-frame photo to realize that Aleona was jumping straight up, so she would still be in the same plane of focus as your pre-focus point. :-)

Reply

20 Ruben August 23, 2011 at 4:11 pm

1. Do you have to use su-800/speedlight as trigger for HSS to work?
2. Do you need it for rear sync also?
3. Or will the new PWs work with both?

Reply

21 Neil vN August 23, 2011 at 4:19 pm

1. No, you don’t need an SU-800 or ST-E2 for high-speed flash sync.
You just need a speedlight and camera that allows it.
High-speed flash sync need not to off-camera flash. You can use your on-camera speedlight in HSS mode.

2. Rear curtain sync and high-speed flash sync are completely unrelated.

You can even say that HSS is the opposite of dragging the shutter. i.e. … a slower shutter speed when using flash. Only THEN can you consider first or rear curtain sync as options.

In fact, this is made quite obvious on the Canon speedlights, where you have 3 options on your speedlight:
a. “nothing going on except the flash going off”
b. high-speed flash sync (the lightning bolt)
c. rear curtain sync.

This makes it impossible to consider the notion of having HSS and rear-curtain sync.

3. The new PWs and the Radio Poppers will work with both modes.

Neil vN

Reply

22 Jess B August 23, 2011 at 4:41 pm

To correct, Aleona is 5’11″ and I’m 5’7″ – still “less majestic” than Aleona, but not by much!!!

Reply

23 Motti August 23, 2011 at 10:28 pm

Yes, when the speed light is on the camera body I can go as high as 1/8000, but I did not know that it was possible with a radio trigger (of-camera like you did). Not mine anyway.

My radio trigger (the cheap version) is capable of shutter speed of maybe 1/160. I was told long ago that the PW can go up to 1/400. I see at B&H site that the new PW you have can go to 1/8000.

I don’t think that any other radio triggers can do that, I maybe wrong.

Reply

24 David Kent August 23, 2011 at 10:57 pm

Philippe Halsman would be flattered! Very nicely lit, and a fun presentation too. Good stuff.

Reply

25 Neil vN August 23, 2011 at 11:50 pm

Oh, we were just trying to comply with the warning sign there, “No Standing Anytime”

Neil vN

Reply

26 simon August 25, 2011 at 3:38 am

Would i be right in saying if you’re using the PW TT system you don’t need to switch HSS on via the flash right? I believe these units intelligently know and take care of business as you select high shutter speeds. If you plug the PW into the computer you can set where the intelligence kicks in.. i think 1/350 is the default setting.

Also a lot more efficient: “Because the new MiniTT1 Transmitter and FlexTT5 Transceiver communicate through-the-shoe with the camera system, they can control the HSS burst duration. By precisely matching flash duration to the shutter speed, large gains in efficiency are found, as much as 70% in many cases, for both remote and on-camera flashes.”

Anyway nice to see this is action Neil, it’s certainly a post i’ve been looking forward to seeing.

Reply

27 Neil vN August 25, 2011 at 11:13 am

Since you mention enabling the HSS via the flash, it sounds like you’re talking about the Canon system.

I’m not sure that HSS would kick in at 1/350 … since with the Canon 5D, the max sync speed is 1/200 and then a 1/350 setting would leave 1/250 as a grey area in terms of the electronics. But then, I haven’t messed around with these default settings at all in the firmware.

Anyway, the TT5 units take care of enabling the flash to go in to HSS territory.

There is one caveat though … your first shot, which establishes communication between Master and Slave, needs to be at or below max sync speed. Unlike the Radio Poppers, you can’t already start off in HSS territory.

Neil vN

Reply

28 simon August 25, 2011 at 1:28 pm

If you play with the HyperSync slider in the firmware you can squeeze 1/250 out of the 5Dmk2′s flash sync speed.. I think -300 is the setting and you need only change it on the TT unit which sits on the camera or all it doesn’t hurt.

I tried it but sometimes you get a very faint dark line from the aperture blades on one side, but only once in a while and it’s very small and easily cropped out.

The online chart for HyperSync (not to be confused with high speed sync can be found here:

Thanks for the heads up regarding communication shot, i didn’t know about that.

Reply

29 Steve bishop August 26, 2011 at 10:58 am

As always Neil, great shot, excellent explanation and outstanding sense of humour. Can’t wait to be on a course of yours here in the UK. Any dates yet?

Reply

30 Neil vN August 26, 2011 at 5:06 pm

Steve … no UK dates for this year. It will only be the dates in Ireland.

Neil vN

Reply

31 parv September 9, 2011 at 7:06 am

Liked the very first image, especially when Jessica while assisting is also above Earth, which is (normally) unexpected.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: