Tangents

photography tutorials, reviews & workshops

tangents photography blog
learn : discuss : share
subscribe today
  • Tangents
  • Tutorials
    • Flash Photography
    • Wedding Photography
    • Studio Photography
    • Posing People
    • Understanding Your Camera
    • Exposure metering
    • BFT
    • Best Photo Books
  • Workshops
    • Info: Workshops
    • In-person
      tutoring sessions
    • Online
      tutoring sessions
    • Video tutorials
    • Workshops in
      New Jersey (NJ)
    • Workshops in
      New York (NYC)
    • Studio Workshop
    • Workshop results
  • Books
    • On-Camera Flash (revised ed.)
    • Direction & Quality of Light
    • Off-Camera Flash Photography
    • Lighting & Design
    • On-Camera Flash (1st ed.)
  • Reviews
    • Nikon
    • Sony
    • Canon
    • Fuji
    • Profoto
    • lighting gear
  • Projects
    • Two Perspectives
    • B&W Infrared
    • Vintage lenses
    • Time-lapse photography
  • Info
    • About
    • Contact
    • My Photo Gear
    • Books by NvN
    • Newsletter
    • Join us on Facebook
    • Acclaim
    • Success Stories
    • Photoshop Actions
  • Forum

Sony A1 : large vs medium RAW highlight recovery

June 29, 2022 Neil vN 1 Comment

Sony A1 : large vs medium RAW highlight recovery

One of the limitations for me about the Sony A1 (Amazon / B&H), was that I couldn’t select a smaller size RAW file than 50 megapixels … until now.  Sony changed that with the release of firmware 1.30 and now there are two further options than the 50 mpx full RAW file. You can now have Medium RAW (21 mpx) and Small RAW (12 mpx). There were immediate reports that the smaller RAW files, don’t have as much leeway for recovering blown highlights. With this video, I wanted to get a clearer idea of what we are up against.

One of the questions I see is why would one want to shoot with a smaller file when the Sony A1 (Amazon / B&H) delivers truly spectacular 50 megapixel files. (The skin tones are just superb!) The answer is that for volume workflow like a wedding and other events, you simply do not need that kind of resolution, and the overhead of the larger file in terms of storage and processing time.With a wedding, you really don’t want or need 50-freaking-megapixels of a bouquet or details.

So this update was really good news for me. With a wedding, I could photograph everything in medium RAW since 21 megapixels are just fine for most uses … and then switch to large RAW for the portraits, bridal party and family photos. In other words, those photos which might more deserver such stunning resolution and detail.

Back to testing how the highlight recovery differ between large and medium and small RAW, I set up a white shirt on a clothing rack in the studio.  It was lit with continuous light set to Daylight WB.

Things to keep in mind:
– This was a non-scientific test. I wanted an idea of the range I could work in with these files.
– I only tested the camera at 400 ISO.  The response might very well be different at other ISO settings.
– We are only looking at the highlight recovery.

So, as with many things you read about photography on the internet, do your own testing to corroborate.

Download the RAW files from this link to make your own comparisons.

 

 

Summary

With the medium and small RAW files, you can easily pull back the highlights by 2/3rds stops for over-exposure. At 1 stop over-exposure, you’re starting to see the medium and small RAW files lose a touch of detail. So I would say that’s about the limit.

From what I see here, I would be happy to use medium RAW, since I would be working well within the margins of 2/3rd stop. If you consistently over-expose more than that, you need to tighten up your technique, imho.  But if you need that kind of dynamic range that the full RAW file offers, then stay with the full RAW fie.

Sony A1 - large vs medium RAW highlight recovery

Filed Under: Sony


 

Help support this website

If you find these articles of value, please help support this website by using these B&H and Amazon affiliate links to order your photo gear.

I also offer photography workshops and tutoring sessions, whether in person, or via online video tutoring sessions.

Stay informed via the monthly newsletter.

Please follow me on Instagram for more.

You can also join our thriving photo community in the Tangents group on Facebook, where we show our photos and discuss all things photography.

Thank you,

Neil vN

Books by Neil van Niekerk


 




1 Comments, Add Your Own

  1. 1Stan says

    September 19, 2022 at 1:49 pm

    Thanks so much for the comparison, Neil! 21mp is just about perfect for volume photography – I really miss the 18mp files from my Canon 1Dx bodies.

    I agree with your findings too, if you’re getting 1-2 stops of overexposure on the back of the screen, you need to make immediate changes to your shooting technique, and not rely on post-production.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

categories

Articles & Tutorials

  • • About myself & this site
    • Books by Neil vN
    • Best photography books
    • Black foamie thing
    • Spinlight 360
    • Photographers’ success stories
    • email newsletter
  • • Flash Photography Techniques
    • Natural looking flash
    • Flash + Ambient light
    • Dragging the shutter
    • Bouncing your flash
    • On-camera flash outdoors
    • Exposure metering
    • Flash exposure compensation
    • Bounce flash examples
    • Which is the best flashgun?
    • Flash brackets
    • Off-camera flash photography
    • Flash photography basics
    • Using video lights
    • Flash photography tips
    • Photography books
  • • Photography workshops NJ / NYC
    • Models @ photography workshops
tutorials:
flash photography
Photography
Workshops

Recent Comments

  • Pat: Right up front, I’ll say I would NEVER buy a Sigma lens. That out of the way, and referring to these...
  • Stuard Santana: Poor Garret Shaw! he should know better, lol I got another one today with the same exact wording and...
  • Mohd Zamri Mohd Zan: In my country are even worst, most guest asking professional photographer to take their photo...
  • HenkW: Thanks for this review – one of the very few I could find on this most interesting topic. So, the...
  • Rachel Abi: Thank you so much for this guide!! There are some many options and you made this really clear :D

All rights reserved. Copyright © Neil van Niekerk 2023 · Customization by The Traveling Designer

Copyright © 2023 · NvN on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in