Off-camera flash in low light – choosing your shutter speed
With flash photography, the maximum flash sync speed is an important camera setting. It is the best go-to camera setting when you use flash in bright ambient light. But when we shoot in low ambient light levels, then we need to adjust our shutter speed accordingly. We would most likely be at a shutter speed where the ambient light shows up. We want some of the ambient light to register in our photographs, because it gives us context. Allowing more ambient light to appear in our low-light photos where we use flash, enhances the mood. It also reveals more of where we are. Context!
To remain at max flash sync speed in low light isn’t the immediate best choice, because the background would usually go far too dark. Even black. Our photographs usually look best with our subject in surroundings we can recognize, or complements our subject in some way.
Shutter speed choice when using flash, will vary depending on what we’re photographing, or trying to achieve. In low light, we’re most often dragging the shutter. But we have to be able to adapt what we do, against what we’re trying to achieve with our photos.
As recap example of using flash in low light, let’s have a closer look at the top image:
I was busy photographing a model, Molly K, for the review of theCanon ST-E3-RT Transmitter and Canon 600EX-RT Speedlite. For a final image, I wanted her against the awesome backdrop of the early evening Manhattan skyline.
The photograph above was my first test shot: 1/30 @ f/5.6 @ 800 ISO.
You can’t use your camera’s light-meter in a general way, since there are dark areas and bright areas. Selectively metering and guesstimating, along with a few test shots, will get us there. I eventually settled on 1/20 @ f/5.0 @ 800 ISO for the settings of the final image.
Working at shutter speeds as low as 1/20 hand-held, will strike fear with some photographers. Alternately, some might be okay with it, saying that “flash will freeze the movement.” Well, yes … but not necessarily. It depends. Or if this was a Facebook relationship status, it would fall under “it’s complicated.”
Flash will only effectively freeze motion, if
– the ambient light on your subject is 4 stops or more under the (proper) flash exposure, and
– there isn’t a bright area behind your subject that will reveal there was movement.
Whether flash will freeze action, is discussed in detail in this article: will flash freeze the action at slow shutter speeds?
Back to the example above – in that straight-forward portrait of our model, there isn’t any movement to contend with, except for potential camera shake. This is where a stabilized lens works wonders. The Nikon 24-120mm f/4 VR (affiliate) and the Canon EF 24-105mm f/4L IS (affiliate), are both superb stabilized lenses for general photography. With the image at the top, there was minimal available light on her, so the flash froze any potential camera shake. Along with a the stabilized lens, a careful stance and breathing, this all ensured that I get crisp images.
Since she wasn’t going to move or jump, the brighter sky behind her wouldn’t show the blur of movement. Flash will freeze action, as long as the subject isn’t moving against a much brighter background – for then we will see some kind of ghosting effect, or parts of our subject might disappear into the brighter areas.
Doing another test shot at my final settings of: 1/20 @ f/5.0 @ 800 ISO, I could easily confirm that camera shake would not be a problem. In this case flash would freeze any movement, whether the model’s or my own. On top of that, I was shooting at a focal length of 24mm, and in comparison, especially with a stabilized lens, a shutter speed of 1/20th isn’t all that scary.
camera settings: 1/20 @ f/5.0 @ 800 ISO
I used a softbox to camera-right, with the Canon 600EX-RT Speedlite (affiliate). The speedlight was in manual exposure mode, and was controlled by the Canon ST-E3 Speedlite Transmitter (affiliate).
I didn’t specifically meter for the flash. From experience, I have a good idea of how powerful my light will be at specific distances with that softbox. With manual flash, we have that specific relationship between Aperture + ISO + Distance + Power, to give us the correct flash exposure. And this remains consistent, even if we shoot on another day in another place.
Camera gear (or equivalents) used in this photo session
- Canon 5D Mark II
- Canon EF 24-105mm f/4L IS / Nikon 24-120mm f/4 VR
- Canon 600EX-RT Speedlite controlled by Canon ST-E3 Transmitter
(or alternately, the Nikon SB-910 Speedlight controlled by PocketWizard FlexTT5 Transceiver & AC3 Controller)
- Lastolite EZYBOX 24×24″ softbox
19 Comments, Add Your Own
1Felipe Anciaes says
Neil, I’m a fan of yours! I can’t wait for a new post at Tangents every week! Thanks a lot! Please, keep it like that!!
Thank you for your generous reply to my question. I was honestly very surprised to see the new post you created staring right at me on the front page. It cleared up the smoke, so thanks again! :)
3Boston Wedding Photographer says
Great stuff Neil, good location and model.
Thanks for another informative article.
Could you explain why you used ISO 800 when you had a f/4 lens? You could have used a larger aperture and a lower ISO. Presumable a lower ISO would have produced a better image quality. Was it because your f/4 lens performs better when stopped down to f/5.6?
6Neil vN says
The choice of shutter speed is not my problem around low levels of ambient light (as shown above), the amount of flash intensity is when both darker & lighter tones are present. The results are unsatisfactory when I do try: shadows are crushed and/or highlights are overexposed when trying to expose for face, skin tone.
8Neil vN says
Love.It. I just love how you think out loud in these posts. It must be the right learning style for my brain because it just makes sense. Thanks Neil!
I second what Jo says in the above post.
The 5th line “And we would like context” …. was that meant to read “And we would LOSE context” ?
12Neil vN says
13patrick clarke says
neil i notice that the lower body is in shadow
how would you correct this if you were shooting a bride and you would like the gown better exposed ?
14Neil vN says
Thanks Neil. What power was your flash set to? 1/2 power? or 1/4 at closer distant to subject?
16Neil vN says
Neil, Just want to say thank for this and the numerous really helpful articles. I like it when you also show how it would be without flash (some writers just show the final pic) and sometimes when you show how it could go wrong.
Consistency with Aperture + ISO + Distance + Power? That sounds interesting. Have you written on this, or will you one day?
18Neil vN says
Thanks for the great article. I got 2 questions.
I was shooting a wedding with people dancing and the room has some background spot lights. I was using 1/320 and f3.2 with ISO 2000. I tried to adjust with the ISO as I need to freeze the dance motion and wanted to keep a relatively narrow depth of field to isolate the subject. I found it very hard balance the bounced flash light to properly show the “context”.
Also, during dinner time, the head table is backed by a wall (with like 3 feet distance), I found the “context” got all wash out by my flash. I tried to adjust my bounced light to different angles and directions but didn’t help.
How would you do that?